Justice Ujjal Bhuyan recently emphasized that judges and lawyers cannot be driven by artificial intelligence (AI) in most cases, highlighting the importance of human judgment and dignity in the legal system. He made these remarks at the National Symposium on AI: Privacy, Security, and IPR held at Maharashtra National Law University (MNLU) in Mumbai.
Justice Bhuyan stated that AI can only be useful in a limited capacity, and human intuition and empathy are essential in many cases. He emphasized that when dealing with natural persons, human dignity is paramount and must be respected, and individual autonomy must be protected.
The concept of privacy was also discussed by Justice Bhuyan, who traced its evolution in India through various legal cases. He highlighted the need to balance the right to privacy with the right to know. The importance of data security and intellectual property rights (IPR) in the age of AI was also addressed, with Justice Bhuyan emphasizing the need for policymakers to create frameworks to protect AI-generated innovations.
The symposium, organized by MNLU Mumbai's Centre for Information Communication Technology and Law and the Centre for Advanced Legal Studies, Training, and Research, aimed to explore the complex interplay between AI innovation and its regulatory challenges. The event featured expert talks and paper presentation sessions, focusing on topics such as the balance between AI innovation and privacy, cybersecurity threats, and the role of AI in combating cybercrime.
Justice Bhuyan's remarks highlight the need for a nuanced approach to the use of AI in the legal system. While AI can be a useful tool in certain contexts, it is essential to recognize its limitations and ensure that human judgment and dignity are preserved. As AI continues to evolve and play a larger role in various aspects of society, it is crucial to consider its potential impact on the legal system and to develop frameworks that balance innovation with protection and respect for human rights.
